Small remarks for 6.0b1

johan98
johan98
Community Member

Some small things (mainly possible design improvements) I noticed while using the new beta version:

On the detail screen for every vault item, regarding the icons for "move to folder", "edit" and "add to favorites":

  • On tablets, they seem to use slight gradients as their background, which is not something the Material Design spec recommends
  • On tablets, the spacing between the icons and the title is a bit too small in my opinion
  • On phones, the "edit" icon should also be visible in the Action Bar instead of going into the overflow menu.
  • You should use the default Material Design icons: https://design.google.com/icons/#ic_folder, https://design.google.com/icons/#ic_edit and, https://design.google.com/icons/#ic_star
  • Is there a reason why you put the icons below the title on tablets and in the Action Bar on phones? They could go into the Action Bar on tablets, as well

The icons in the navigation drawer can also be replaced with the default Material Design ones:
https://design.google.com/icons/#ic_star, https://design.google.com/icons/#ic_folder, https://design.google.com/icons/#ic_settings (I didn't find one for "Categories").

And the icons for "cancel" and "save" when editing an item can also be replaced:
https://design.google.com/icons/#ic_close, https://design.google.com/icons/#ic_done

On tablets, the animation of the 1Password logo when expanding the drawer looks strange. Why does it move to the top before starting to scale? Also, the logo seems a little pixelated (tested on Nexus 5X and Nexus 9).

On tablets, when I select "Categories" in the drawer and then one of the categories (for example "Logins"), then go to another drawer item (for example "Favorites") and then back to "Categories", the "Logins" category is still selected. The same behavior is observed with "Folders". This could be confusing.

More transition animations could be added, for example when the Floating Action Button for adding an item is clicked or when selecting an item/a category/a folder and going to the corresponding detail screen.

When a search returns no results, the message "All objects are shown here, sorted by category" is displayed (at least in the German translation). The message should rather state that the search returned no results ;)

In a long list of Login items, when you scroll near the bottom, the scrollbar only reaches about 2/3 of the height. Then it quickly drops to the bottom while scrolling below the last item. That is probably not intentional.

The integrated browser has not yet got any Material Design. I hope it will also be updated.

The dialogs for editing and viewing login items' notes is way too large on tablets.

On tablets, the view for adding and editing items should either be shown as a dialog or on the right side, where the details of items are shown when not editing them. In the current state, the text fields span the whole screen width, which doesn't look nice on tablets in landscape orientation.

When a login item is opened that has TOTP, there is a text saying "Section" above the current One-Time-Password

The title of the screen for entering the Master Password when using the 1Password keyboard for filling is "1password" with a lowercase "p".


1Password Version: 6.0b1
Extension Version: Not Provided
OS Version: Android 6.0.1
Sync Type: Not Provided

Comments

  • Wow @johan98! You've identified a lot of improvements that we can make and thankfully I can say that many of these are already on our roadmap. You've also brought up some new ones that I will be raising with our development team as well. Thank you for the very detailed feedback!

This discussion has been closed.